Mix and Match PIES
Pick 2 or more flavors
  • Save up to 15%
  • One 10" Pie Per Box
  • Ships Frozen and Ready to Bake
1
Choose Your Products
Pick 2 or more flavors
  • Save up to 15%
  • One 10" Pie Per Box
  • Ships Frozen and Ready to Bake
Includes 0 Pies!

  • 0
  • 6
Includes 0 Pies!
2
Add to Cart With Savings!

From Freezer to Fresh-Baked

Baking Instructions

Follow these steps for a golden, flaky pie baked fresh at home.

🥧
Ready-to-bake
from frozen
🔥

Step 1 — Preheat Oven + Pan

Prior to baking, place a sheet pan in the oven and preheat the oven and pan according to the chart below.

🥧

Step 2 — Remove Pie From Freezer

Remove pie from freezer. Remove from carton and remove overwrap.

🥚

Step 3 — Egg Wash the Top

Immediately egg wash the top of the unbaked pie — not the crimped edge — with a mixture of 2 parts egg to 1 part water.

🔪

Step 4 — Cut Steam Vents

Cut 4 slivers into the dough at the 3, 6, 9, and 12 o’clock positions to allow steam to escape during baking.

📄

Step 5 — Use Parchment + Hot Pan

Carefully place a sheet of parchment paper and then the frozen pie on the hot sheet pan in the oven.

⏲️

Step 6 — Reduce Temp + Bake

Immediately reduce the oven temperature according to the chart below and bake as directed.

⚠️

Please note: Oven types and models can differ widely in their baking characteristics; the baking instructions below may require adjustments based on your particular oven.

💨 Convection Oven — Low Fan

Preheat Temp 400°F
Baking Temp 325°F
Baking Time 60–65 mins

🏠 Conventional Oven

Preheat Temp 425°F
Baking Temp 350°F
Baking Time 70–80 mins